ARC Book Review: The Burning Sky by Sherry Thomas

Posted September 15, 2013 by Debby in Book Reviews

I received this book for free from Publisher via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. Thank you!! This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

ARC Book Review: The Burning Sky by Sherry ThomasThe Burning Sky by Sherry Thomas
Series: The Elemental Trilogy #1
Published by Balzer + Bray on September 17th, 2013
Genres: Young Adult, Historical Fiction, Fantasy
Pages: 464
Format: eARC
Source: Publisher via Edelweiss

It all began with a ruined elixir and an accidental bolt of lightning…

Iolanthe Seabourne is the greatest elemental mage of her generation—or so she's being told. The one prophesied for years to be the savior of The Realm. It is her duty and destiny to face and defeat the Bane, the greatest mage tyrant the world has ever known. A suicide task for anyone let alone a sixteen-year-old girl with no training, facing a prophecy that foretells a fiery clash to the death.

Prince Titus of Elberon has sworn to protect Iolanthe at all costs but he's also a powerful mage committed to obliterating the Bane to avenge the death of his family—even if he must sacrifice both Iolanthe and himself to achieve his goal.

But Titus makes the terrifying mistake of falling in love with the girl who should have been only a means to an end. Now, with the servants of the Bane closing in, he must choose between his mission and her life.

4.5 Stars

The Burning Sky is one of those books with a premise and a cover that pretty much had me salivating. It sounded perfect for me. It hit all the right notes. And while I recognized many points on which the book could have been better, this was such an engaging and absorbing read that I loved it all the same.

Let’s get the elephant out of the room: the romance. It is… amazing. Irresistible. Addicting. Iolanthe and Titus have a chemistry that drips off the page. It didn’t take long at all for me to be head over heels for them. It was just the right kind of development for me: starting off with mild interest, turning to disdain, turning to fervently denying any affections and trying to resist… but it being inevitable and unavoidable. All around though, the slightest mention of any affection between the two main characters had my heart pounding. It was just so beautiful. And then you end up with irresistibly adorable quotes like…

Now he could work her likeness into any story of his choosing.
Now he could fight dragons for her.
And now he could kiss her again. The Burning Sky by Sherry Thomas


This leads perfectly into my immense love for the main characters. Iolanthe, the elemental mage of prophecy, gets recruited to go on a quest to save the realm from the Bane, a tyrant mage of Atlantis, by the Prince, Titus. The book actually gets told from the alternating perspectives of Iolanthe and Titus. If you know me at all, you’ll know that I’m not typically a fan of alternating perspectives. But, here it wasn’t alternating chapters – sometimes they switched multiple times in one chapter, and each switch felt necessary. Not only because you see the two characters gradually falling for each other (which is irresistible, as we have established), but also because they have such different motives and perspectives during their mission. Their voices, in that sense, were also really distinctive. Titus, the prince, is absolutely charming in every way, even though he can act like a prick – and does that as an act to the outside world. But his bravery and dedication run so deep that I absolutely love him. Iolanthe starts off completely frightened by the situation, and then starts resenting Titus (due to spoilery circumstances). Over the story though, she develops and grows in a huge way, and by the end she is so courageous and confident, that it’s almost like she’s a totally different person. It’s character development at its very best.

The plot itself had its ups and downs. The beginning was strong, with Titus coming to rescue Iolanthe and them running to safety while being introduced to the prophecy and the two wonderful main characters. The middle, however, could have been way stronger. While I liked reading more about the characters and the budding romance, the plot had its moments where I was wondering where in the world it was going. However, the end pulled it all together again. It was fast-paced, heart stopping action that I just loved, with magic, dragons, battles, political intrigue, etc. In short, it took a while to get there, but the plot was convincing too.

So while for most of this book I was so overcome by feels that I managed to ignore any prevailing negatives, I do recognize that this book wasn’t perfect. Most of my qualms (in fact, all of them) related to the world building. See, young adult high fantasy is hard to accomplish. Younger readers are less tolerant of the long exposition sections typical to high fantasy: the info-dumps that create the world. However, in high fantasy, you’re creating a world from scratch, so to be thorough, those info-dumps are almost necessary. The Burning Sky did not contain those info-dump expositions, so younger readers won’t be scared off. But, this means the world was a bit underdeveloped for my taste, and I was left with a lot of unanswered questions.

For instance, there are different types of magic: elemental magic, subtle magic, and mind magic. What each type entails and where the boundaries lie remains extremely vague. Also, all throughout the book I was wondering whether the people in the human world knew about the existence of magic or not – because it’s never explicitly stated either way. And I was also confused about the intersection between the magic realms and the nonmage realms – are they in the same plane, are they different dimensions, or what? I couldn’t figure it out, and as a bit of a world building fanatic, that did bother me. I wanted a map (especially of the capital city in the magic realm) and I just wanted clarity, especially also in some scenes where magic was used and the descriptions were so rushed and vague that I couldn’t picture it that well in my imagination. But, as a reader who obsesses over world building, the fact that I managed to ignore this issue so well, due to the overwhelming and beautiful feels, means that the book doesn’t suffer so much from this. It’s still an absolutely wonderful read. (Here’s hoping this is cleared up in the sequel!)

Summing Up:

Seriously, this is a favorite. This is a Debby Book™. This beautiful story, and especially the romance, had me flailing around on my bed, seriously stifling sobs and squeals. It struck me in the heart like Cupid’s arrow. I will be rereading this so often, and the world building issue is almost negligible at this point. I just love it! I will go crazy for an ARC of the sequel, because I need that in my hands as soon as humanly possible.

GIF it to me straight!


Recommended To:

People who like FEELS (AKA everyone), and fans of Throne of Glass and Shadow and Bone.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

21 responses to “ARC Book Review: The Burning Sky by Sherry Thomas

  1. I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS BOOK!!! The romance! The world building! TITUS! The long ago time at boarding school outside of London, I love it all! AND OH MY GOSH I MADE YOUR BLOG SECOND OPINION! MADE MY DAY!!:):):):)

  2. latenightswithgoodbooks

    This sounds wonderful and I feel like there's a distinct possibility that this will also end up becoming an Amanda book. I love reading about various magic systems and I'm so intrigued by the 3 different ones that Thomas has set up in her book. I do know what you mean about world building qualms – there's hardly ever a case of too much world building for my tastes. But since this is a series, we can just hope that Thomas has a lot more planned on that front. Lovely review, Debby!
    My recent post Review: The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller

  3. 😀 😀 😀 that is pretty much the best thing to ever hear as a book blogger! I hope you enjoy this if you do decide to buy it ….which you should 😛 😛 YAY

  4. YES YES YES TO EVERYTHING. I want the next book SO BAD. And I just want to reread this immediately. And flail over all the feels. asdfjkl; OF COURSE YOU MADE SECOND OPINION. Hahaha. Gotta get more people to read this 😉

  5. Yay! So excited to hear that this one have a great romance. I have an ARC of this, but I haven't read it yet. Now that you said that it had an amazing romance and main character, I think I'll read that ASAP. Sad to hear that the world was a bit undeveloped, though. I've had quite a high expectation for its world building because the blurb sounds promising.
    Thanks for the review!

    Neysa @

  6. christinamofranke

    Better a month late than never, right? RIGHT?

    Yes yes yes, Iolanthe and Titus. I love them. And, yeah, he is a bit of a prick sometimes, but he would be unrealistic otherwise. He has a lot of shit on his shoulders, and he can't be making all of his decisions with his prick, even if the end result is, ironically, acting like one.

    Reviews for this have been all over. I thought the plot was fine, but the world building was wibbly wobbly all the way through. Like, this came from there and that from there and what are our fairy tales doing in there?

    Bahahaha, Debby Book tm. That's fab.
    My recent post Cover Snark 75: The One Where Your TBR Pile Is Not Ready

  7. RIGHT hahahaha

    EXACTLY. I loved Titus because his character was so well developed and thorough… I mean, his behavior HAD CAUSE. That's the way you can make a main character act like a prick. Give them a reason.

    I haven't seen many other reviews for this but I just know I loved the adventure. World building is definitely an issue, but the rest was SO MUCH FUN. I at least tried to warn people that it's not a flawless book. *shrug*


  8. Heather

    Fantastic review. In fact, when I read this it convinced me I need to buy this book. (And I did!) The romance sounds like its swoon worthy. And even better if its a slow build one.

  9. I liked it. Sometimes it’s hard to buy the romance in YA books, but Sherry Thomas always sells the romance in her books and I bought it in this one. The magic system was a little confusing, especially the thing with the portals at the end. I’ve noticed that the YA books that I’ve been reading recently have multiple points of view (which I hate), but two povs are manageable. I also liked that while this is a trilogy, it didn’t end on a cliff hanger.